Decide what to say before anyone designs a page
By Lee Fuhr · Published · Updated
It’s unfortunately rare that someone comes to me and says, “I need help figuring out what to say.”
They say they need a website. Or just a web page, or maybe a new sales deck. Something they can see (and put on an invoice that’ll get approved by the bean counters). But most of the time they just want a pretty new website that they can feel proud of, and I walk them through my process.
Sometimes they know their website is not converting. Often it’s just old and needs updating to fit in with its decade. If that’s you, if your website exists but doesn’t convert, your priority maybe shouldn’t be a redesign. First, you need to know what to say.
A website is easy to explain to your CFO or your board. “We hired someone to redo the website” easily elicits risk-averse nods. “We hired someone to figure out our messaging” can suck the air out of the room and replace it with doubt.
Almost nobody asks for messaging, so few service providers offer it. Agencies often assume clients won’t pay for it. So they go straight to pages and layouts. You end up with something that says nothing (but sure looks good doing it).
Every word on every page comes from a decision about what to say. That decision gets made. Usually badly, in a quick call where someone says what amounts to, “Let’s keep it simple, show them our equipment, drop a contact form, and move on.” By the time a designer shows up, the “what we’re saying” decisions are often already settled.
Those decisions should come down to three things, and it’s vital to attack them in order: value, benefits, features.
Value is the world they wish they lived in and that you can deliver to them. It’s the bigger goal your customer is after, the one all your benefits add up to. That’s the vital value you can bring into their lives.
Benefits are something new they can do, be, or feel because of you. I call them superpowers: what they can suddenly do or be that they couldn’t before, thanks to you.
Features come last. Each one backs up a benefit. They prove you can deliver those benefits.
Some people just want the website. Sure, that’s fine. But if nobody has ever asked you what you want to say, that’s the first work to do.
What works is a different set of questions. “What do you want someone to feel after reading this?” Instead of “What pages do you need?”, try “What do you wish people understood about your company?” Instead of “What’s your timeline?”, try another good one: “What would your sales team wish their incoming leads already knew?”