Get the headline right, then design around it
By Lee Fuhr · Published · Updated
Most of the time, normal people just want their new site to look sharp. It’s easy for a self-serious designer to lead the next conversation talking about whitespace and gradients. That’s even been me… hey, I like a good-looking site as much as anyone. Then we get to the homepage, and the headline says nothing. Something like “Innovating the solution to whatever.” Nope, stop.
Most visitors skim the headline, and for plenty of them it’s the only thing they read. It tells them, in the few seconds they’re willing to give you, whether they’re in the right place and whether they’re willing to give you more of their attention. (A 2025 Clutch survey found that 83% of people say they judge a website’s credibility in under 20 seconds.) If that headline is generic, you won’t hook ’em, and they’ll leave.
One client came to me for a freshen-up. New look, new energy, something that didn’t sound like every other consultancy. Their homepage headline said something about “solutions for high-achieving businesses”. I told them, “You can’t design around that. The headline is primary. Then we’ll think about whatever fonts we’re going to pick for the copy.” That got their attention. They probably expected the designer to start talking about modern art.
So through my process, I asked them questions. What’s the villain in their story? What do you want to be known for? If you could completely rewrite your reputation, what would it be? What would the sales team wish their incoming leads already thought or knew? Slowly, the real message came out. No alienating jargon, no obfuscating cleverness.
Once we boiled that down into a headline, the design decisions got easier and, more importantly, more grounded. The copy told us what to highlight, what came first. It set the tone. A headline is the value in a line: how their world is different because of what you do, the world as they wish it were. That’s the vital value you can bring into their lives.
Get the words right first. Design moves faster because every layout decision has something to follow. Words are fast. As you figure out what to say, you backspace and redo it. I can bomb out a dozen strong headlines and a page of copy in an hour or two. A redesign takes days.
So that’s why I start with copy. Before the mood board or the layout, long before anyone brings up the logo or color values. Skip it, and you’re dressing up a generic headline in pretty fonts. Lipstick on a pig, which will hold back even the best-looking site. A clear headline can make an average design perform. Be clear, not clever.