# 574 sites didn’t make the study base

By [Lee Fuhr](https://leefuhr.com/about) · Published Oct 8, 2026 · Updated Oct 30, 2026

If you own or market a manufacturing shop, I’d probably skip to the end. The middle is me showing my work, including the bit I got wrong.

4,402 manufacturer websites passed eligibility and went through the read. I read every page I could capture and ended up with a study base of 3,828. So what happened to the other 574?

I figured it was housekeeping. Turns out one of the four ways a site leaves the base is a judgment call, and one of my rules was just wrong.

## I can’t score a cookie banner

11 errored outright. Another 431 captured something that was not the company’s own content. Here’s what came back:

- 278 captured navigation only.
- 115 captured a cookie banner.
- 19 came back empty.
- 14 returned a 403 (four of them with *“Invalid SSL certificate Error code 526”*).
- 5 sat behind a JavaScript wall.

All I got from Monroe Engineering was its own navigation. I left all of them out. I kept asking whether a page had nothing on it, or whether I’d failed to find what was there. Count them as companies that said nothing and I’m making a claim about their writing, when the failure was in my capture. The headline number would look tidy and mean the wrong thing.

That leaves 3,960 sites with real content. Now I have to make some calls.

## 65 are a subdomain of somebody else’s site

`catalog.reesinc.com`, `products.kuriyama.com`, `us.dmgmori.com`, `hydroforming.schulergroup.com`, `southwest.swagelok.com`. Six start with **catalog**, five with **products**, and four are regional Swagelok distributor pages.

Real companies, some of them big. I left them out because I’m looking at what a shop puts on its homepage. A product catalog on a subdomain is a different page. Asking a parts catalog whether it names a problem its customer has is a stupid test.

## 25 have a headline that reads “All Categories”

`diecastingmanufacturers.com`, `aluminum-extrusions.net`, `contract-manufacturers.org`, `broachingjobshops.com`, `aluminumanodizing.com`. Every one is a directory dressed as a manufacturer. The biggest words on every page give it away: **All Categories** or **Related Categories**.

I tried the domain name first. A domain with “companies” or “manufacturers” in it looked like an easy way to spot a directory.

It caught four real firms: `jecompanies.com`, `eaglegroupmanufacturers.com`, `hopewellcompanies.com`, `isccompanies.com`.

So much for that.

So I threw the rule away and looked at what the page does. A directory says what it is in its own headline.

## 14 sell what somebody else made

`sterlingseal.com` (*“Large Selection of O Rings, Gaskets, Filters”*), `circlevalve.com` (*“Stocking Distributor of Industrial Valves”*), `bearingsandindustrialsupply.com`. Distributors or manufacturers’ reps, with nothing anywhere on the site to say they make anything: no equipment or tolerance, no process they perform, no finishing, no assembly.

A distributor that also machines parts stays in, as long as anything on the site says it made something.

## 28 I took out by hand, one at a time

The other three rules are mechanical. These I vetted by reading the site and deciding it didn’t belong. I wrote down a reason for each one I took out. Without a reason, this is just a list of sites I didn’t like.

Here’s what that looks like, a few to show the range:

- **thebluebook.com** is a commercial construction directory. **jobshopsohio.com** says *“700+ Ohio Manufacturers Listed In This Directory”*. **top.parts** says *“Find America’s Top Custom Manufacturers Near You”*.
- **digitalleadership.com** is a strategy consultancy. It turned up because its homepage opens *“Strategy is the last handmade process in your company”*. I like that line more than almost any opening a real shop in the study wrote.
- **mfgskillsct.com** is a Connecticut state workforce program. **metalforamerica.org** is a defense metals advocacy group. **fuzehub.com** is a New York State nonprofit.
- **brmcginty.com** has a callout in its hero that reads *“AC OUT IN THIS HEAT?”*. That’s excellent writing for a homeowner with a dead air conditioner. **bendheating.com** guarantees your Carrier installation. Both are contractors, not parts makers.
- **cnc-pros.com** sells and services machine tools. It slipped past the distributor rule because it names processes it sells rather than performs.

Six of the 28 turned up in a single afternoon, all for the same reason: I was checking every site in the study that opens by naming a problem its customer has, and the non-manufacturers were disproportionately good at it.

A consultancy, a workforce program, and an HVAC contractor all lead with a problem. Seven of 3,828 manufacturers name one in the opening. Two put a real customer problem in the headline itself.

## The eleven I nearly threw away

I’d rather not have this section.

My subdomain rule counted dots. Two or more dots meant a subdomain, because `catalog.reesinc.com` has two and `reesinc.com` has one. That’s true in the United States and false for addresses like these, it turns out. **lestercast.co.uk** carries two dots by construction. So do **llewellinsgears.co.uk**, **westinengineering.co.uk**, **wrightsplastics.co.uk**, **get-it-made.co.uk**, **ansini.co.uk**, **3dprint-uk.co.uk**, **brunitec.com.br**, and three more.

Eleven real manufacturers were out of the study, most of them British, because of how their web address was built.

I’d made the same mistake twice in one study. The directory rule caught four real firms because I thought their names looked wrong. This rule did the same thing with dots. If I’m going to judge a name by its shape, I need to nail down which shapes are legitimate. My rule only recognized the American ones.

The fix is a proper test of the domain ending, one that accounts for country-code second-level domains, with eight test cases. That includes `a.b.co.uk`, which really is a subdomain and would break a naive fix.

Two of the thirteen the fix rescued still came out: the British Plastics Federation is a trade association, and mig-welding.co.uk is a DIY guide.

## Ask who came out

Every number in this study is a count, not a sample. So who I let into the count matters.

The base moved four times in one day, from 3,825 to 3,819 to 3,830 to 3,828. I kept reading the sites. They kept giving me reasons to change what the filter had done.

I keep asking shops to count things in their own writing. A page that says *“we serve a wide range of industries”* hasn’t counted anything. A page that says *“we have run 17,000 jobs for 40 customers in three industries, and here are two of them”* has. So I owe the reader that same care when I put a number on a finding.

When I see a big percentage, I dig in and confirm it before I trust it. When somebody hands me a number about a market, I want to know what got left out of the count and why. If they can’t tell me, I don’t know what they’ve counted.

*Every quote from a site here I matched word for word against the page as I captured it in September 2026.*

## Thirty minutes, and you’ll know what I’d fix

[Pick a time](https://cal.com/leefuhr/30i)

Straight answers. You’ll hear what the fix would cost, and if it isn’t worth the money, I’ll say so.

Or write to me: [lee@leefuhr.com](mailto:lee@leefuhr.com)

More from me

[The Commodity Test](https://areyougeneric.com)

Checks whether your site sounds like everyone else’s. It takes 30 seconds and asks for no email.

[Every article from the study](https://leefuhr.com/articles/)

The full list, one line each, with what it found.

[Tools](https://leefuhr.com/tools)

A suite of small, sharp tools for manufacturers and trades companies, most free to try.

[Sharp Questions](https://leefuhr.com/sharp-questions)

A discovery-call tool with a live fit score, $90 one time.
